Caramel color (E150a–d)
Updated October 5, 2026
Caramel color (E150a-d) is the most widely used food coloring in the world, made by heating sugars under controlled conditions. It is not the same thing as caramel candy. The safety discussion is not about the color itself but about 4-MEI, a by-product formed in the ammonia-processed types used in colas and soy sauce, which is classified as possibly carcinogenic on the basis of animal data.
Quick facts
- Also known as
- Caramel coloring, E150a, E150b, E150c, E150d
- E-number
- E150a–d
- Function
- Colors
- US status
- Approved color additive, exempt from batch certification (21 CFR 73.85), regulated as a single "caramel" rather than by class; the by-product 4-MEI is under FDA post-market review
- EU status
- Permitted as four separate additives: E150a plain, E150b caustic sulfite, E150c ammonia, E150d sulfite ammonia caramel
- Acceptable daily intake
- Group ADI 300 mg per kg of body weight per day; 100 mg/kg for Class III (E150c) (EFSA, 2011). JECFA: 200 mg/kg for Classes III and IV
- Found in
- 42,613 products (24,443 sold in the US)
- Foodmetria concern level
- Moderate concern How we rate additives
What is Caramel color?
Caramel color is made by heating carbohydrates — dextrose, sucrose, molasses, starch hydrolysates — under controlled conditions, usually with an acid, alkali or salt to steer the reaction. The result is a dark brown liquid or powder used purely as a color. Despite the name, it is not caramel candy and contributes essentially no sweetness.
There are four industrial types, and they are not interchangeable:
- Class I (E150a), plain caramel — no ammonium or sulfite compounds. Used in spirits, some baked goods.
- Class II (E150b), caustic sulfite caramel — sulfite, no ammonium. Used in some spirits.
- Class III (E150c), ammonia caramel — made with ammonium compounds. Beer, soy sauce, gravies, pet food.
- Class IV (E150d), sulfite ammonia caramel — both. The acid-stable type used in colas and other soft drinks.
The EU regulates these as four separate additives with separate E numbers. The US does not: 21 CFR 73.85 covers "caramel" as a single color additive, exempt from batch certification, with no class distinction. So a US label reading "caramel color" does not tell you which type is inside — which matters, because the by-product discussed below forms only in Classes III and IV.
Why is Caramel color used in food?
Caramel color is used because it is cheap, extremely stable and shade-adjustable from pale gold to near-black. It survives acid, heat, light and long shelf lives better than almost any other color, which is why it is in cola, beer, soy sauce, gravies, sauces, bread, vinegar and whisky.
It also does a job that is easy to miss: it makes products look consistent. Soy sauce, stout and balsamic vinegar vary batch to batch, and caramel color evens that out. In colas it is the color — a cola without it is clear.
Is Caramel color safe? What the research says
What regulators say about the color. FDA permits caramel for coloring foods generally under good manufacturing practice. EFSA re-evaluated all four classes in 2011 and set a group acceptable daily intake of 300 mg per kg of body weight per day, derived from a no-effect level of 30 g/kg in rats with a 100-fold safety margin. It gave Class III a lower individual ADI of 100 mg/kg because of new information on the immune effects of THI (2-acetyl-4-tetrahydroxybutylimidazole), another compound formed in ammonia processing. The WHO/FAO expert committee set 200 mg/kg for Classes III and IV back in 1985.
Where it gets interesting: exposure. EFSA concluded that anticipated dietary exposure for both children and adults may exceed the ADIs for Classes I, III and IV, while Class II stayed below. These are very large numbers in absolute terms — 100 mg/kg is 3 g a day for a 30 kg child — so the exceedance reflects how much caramel color is used across the diet, not a small margin. This is the main reason this page sets concern at moderate rather than low.
4-MEI. 4-methylimidazole is a by-product that forms when ammonium compounds are used, so it is present in Classes III and IV and not in Classes I and II. The facts, separated:
- IARC evaluated 4-MEI in Volume 101 of its monographs and classified it in Group 2B, possibly carcinogenic to humans. The basis was explicit: "no data were available" in humans, and "sufficient evidence in experimental animals."
- California listed 4-MEI under Proposition 65 on January 7, 2011, following a National Toxicology Program finding, and set a No Significant Risk Level of 29 micrograms per day.
- Measured exposure. Smith et al. (PLOS ONE, 2015) tested 12 beverages and found 4-MEI ranging from about 10 µg/L in one diet cola to roughly 950 µg/L in a malt beverage. Regular consumption of the higher-4-MEI products put intake above California's 29 µg/day level; the lowest products were far below it. Samples bought in California were consistently lower than those from New York, which the authors read as the warning requirement having changed manufacturing.
- EFSA, assessing 4-MEI exposure from caramel colors in 2011, considered it not of concern.
- FDA has 4-MEI on its list of chemicals under post-market review, with the status "risk management review." The color additive itself is not on that list.
Put together: IARC classified an impurity on animal data, California set a strict exposure level for it, product levels vary by more than a hundredfold between brands, and the two food-safety agencies that assessed dietary exposure to it reached reassuring conclusions. "Caramel color causes cancer" is not what any of these documents say.
Bottom line: the color itself has a very high safety margin and a real exposure question. The impurity question is narrower than headlines suggest and is specific to the ammonia-processed types — which, on a US label, you cannot identify.
Caramel color regulation: US vs EU
| Region | Status |
|---|---|
| United States | Permitted and exempt from batch certification (21 CFR 73.85), regulated as a single color additive called "caramel" with no class distinction. The by-product 4-MEI is on FDA's list of chemicals under post-market review ("risk management review"). Not part of the FDA synthetic dye phase-out. |
| California | 4-MEI has been listed under Proposition 65 as a carcinogen since January 7, 2011, with a No Significant Risk Level of 29 micrograms per day. Caramel color itself is not banned or restricted. |
| European Union | Permitted as four separate additives — E150a (plain), E150b (caustic sulfite), E150c (ammonia) and E150d (sulfite ammonia) — each with its own purity specification limiting by-products including 4-MEI. |
| United Kingdom | Permitted under the same four entries as retained EU law. |
| Codex / JECFA | ADI of 0–200 mg/kg bw for Class III (ammonia caramel) and Class IV (sulfite ammonia caramel), set in 1985. |
| IARC | 4-MEI, a by-product of ammonia-processed caramel colors, classified in Group 2B (possibly carcinogenic to humans) in IARC Monographs Volume 101, on the basis of animal data; no human data were available. |
Caramel color is approved in the US, the EU and the UK, and it is not part of the US move away from synthetic dyes: it does not appear on FDA's tracker of petroleum-based dyes being phased out, and it is not in the state dye laws, which cover certified synthetic colors. What is under review is 4-MEI, which FDA lists among the chemicals under post-market review with the status "risk management review."
The regulatory structures differ in a way that affects what you can learn from a label. In the EU, the four classes are four additives with separate E numbers and separate purity specifications, which cap the levels of 4-MEI and THI. In the US, 21 CFR 73.85 defines a single color additive called "caramel," and the ingredient list normally says only "caramel color" or "caramel coloring."
California's Proposition 65 operates separately from food-additive approval: 4-MEI has been on the list since January 7, 2011 with a No Significant Risk Level of 29 µg/day, which is why some manufacturers reformulated products sold there.
Who should limit or avoid Caramel color?
- People who drink several colas or other dark soft drinks a day. This is the group whose 4-MEI intake the published measurements actually put above California's threshold. Brands differ by more than a hundredfold, so switching products matters as much as cutting back.
- People with a sulfite sensitivity. Classes II and IV are made with sulfite compounds. US labels do not identify the class, so if sulfites are a problem for you this is worth asking a manufacturer about rather than guessing.
- People avoiding gluten. Caramel color is usually made from corn in North America, but the starting material varies by region and producer, so "caramel color" alone is not a guarantee. Rely on a gluten-free claim rather than on the ingredient name.
- Anyone cutting back on ultra-processed food. Caramel color is one of the most reliable markers of a processed product, and it appears in categories people do not expect — bread, vinegar, stock, sauces.
- Vegans and vegetarians. Caramel color is made from plant carbohydrates and is suitable for both.
Foods that commonly contain Caramel color
Share of published products in each category whose ingredient list includes Caramel color.
Popular products with Caramel color
c NOVA 4
e NOVA 4
e NOVA 4
e NOVA 4
e NOVA 4
e NOVA 4
c NOVA 4
c NOVA 4
c NOVA 4
d NOVA 4 Caramel color-free alternatives
Popular products from the same categories that don't list Caramel color and score Nutri-Score A–C.
c
c NOVA 3
b NOVA 3
a NOVA 3
c NOVA 4 How to spot Caramel color on a label
Look for any of these names in the ingredient list:
Related additives
Frequently asked questions
Is caramel color the same as caramel?
No. Caramel candy is sugar cooked for flavor; caramel color is made by heating carbohydrates under controlled conditions purely to produce a brown pigment, and it adds essentially no sweetness or caramel taste.
Does caramel color cause cancer?
No regulator has concluded that. IARC classified 4-MEI — a by-product formed in the ammonia-processed types used in colas and soy sauce — as possibly carcinogenic to humans (Group 2B), explicitly on animal data with no human data available. EFSA assessed dietary 4-MEI exposure as not of concern, and FDA has it under review.
What is 4-MEI and which foods have it?
It is a compound formed when ammonium compounds are used to make caramel color, so it appears in Class III (E150c, used in beer, soy sauce and gravies) and Class IV (E150d, used in colas) and not in Classes I and II. Measured levels differ by more than a hundredfold between brands of the same drink.
Why does California have a warning about it?
California listed 4-MEI under Proposition 65 in January 2011 after a National Toxicology Program finding, and set a No Significant Risk Level of 29 micrograms per day. Products above that level require a warning there, which prompted some manufacturers to reformulate for the California market.
How much caramel color is safe per day?
EFSA's group ADI is 300 mg per kg of body weight, with 100 mg/kg for Class III — roughly 9 g and 3 g a day for a 30 kg (66 lb) child, and 21 g and 7 g for a 70 kg (154 lb) adult. EFSA also found that typical diets may exceed those limits for Classes I, III and IV, which is unusual among food colors.
Is caramel color gluten-free and vegan?
It is vegan. Gluten depends on the starting material, which varies by producer and region — corn is usual in North America. "Caramel color" on its own is not a gluten-free guarantee, so rely on a gluten-free claim.
Is caramel color banned in Europe?
No. All four classes are permitted in the EU and the UK as E150a to E150d, each with purity specifications that limit by-products. The EU regulates them as four distinct additives, while US labels say only "caramel color."
Sources & references
- 21 CFR 73.85 — Caramel
- EFSA (2011). Scientific Opinion on the re-evaluation of caramel colours (E 150a,b,c,d) as food additives. EFSA Journal 9(3):2004
- JECFA — Caramel colour, Class III (ammonia caramel), evaluation summary
- JECFA — Caramel colour, Class IV (sulfite ammonia caramel), evaluation summary
- IARC Monographs Volume 101 — Some Chemicals Present in Industrial and Consumer Products, Food and Drinking-water (4-methylimidazole)
- California OEHHA — Proposition 65 chemical listing: 4-methylimidazole
- Smith T.J.S. et al. (2015). Caramel Color in Soft Drinks and Exposure to 4-Methylimidazole: A Quantitative Risk Assessment. PLOS ONE 10(2):e0118138
- U.S. FDA — List of Select Chemicals in the Food Supply Under FDA Review
Product data: Open Food Facts (ODbL), updated daily. Additive information is for general education and is not medical advice. Always check the package label. Our methodology.