Top 10 · Updated November 2026

Least Processed Toaster Pastries

10 of the top 10 toaster pastries products sit in NOVA group 4 — the least processed end of the scale. The toaster pastries with the lowest NOVA processing group — fewer industrial ingredients and additives. We checked 91 toaster pastries with complete data.

  1. 1 Toaster Pastries - Brown Sugar Cinnamon

    Toaster Pastries - Brown Sugar Cinnamon

    Katz · 227g
    c NOVA 4 220 kcal 13 g sugar 2 g protein 7 g fat
  2. 2 Toaster pastries, frosted blueberry

    Toaster pastries, frosted blueberry

    Kellogg's · 416 g
    c NOVA 4 208 kcal 16.7 g sugar 2.1 g protein 5.2 g fat
  3. 3 Frosted strawberry toaster pastries, strawberry

    Frosted strawberry toaster pastries, strawberry

    Kellogg's · 416 g
    d NOVA 4 385 kcal 30.8 g sugar 3.9 g protein 9.6 g fat
  4. 4 Toast'em Pop-Ups Frosted Blueberry Pastries

    Toast'em Pop-Ups Frosted Blueberry Pastries

    Toast'Em Pop-Ups · 10.2 oz
    d NOVA 4 340 kcal 30.8 g sugar 3 g protein 8 g fat
  5. 5 Pop Tarts Raspberry Flavour

    Pop Tarts Raspberry Flavour

    Kellogg's
    d NOVA 4 400 kcal 32 g sugar 4 g protein 10 g fat
  6. 6 Toaster Strudel pastries strawberry

    Toaster Strudel pastries strawberry

    Pillsbury · 11.7 oz
    d NOVA 4 306 kcal 17.3 g sugar 4.6 g protein 10.9 g fat
  7. 7 Apple Jacks Pop Tarts

    Apple Jacks Pop Tarts

    Kellogg's · 384g
    d NOVA 4 385 kcal 29.2 g sugar 4.2 g protein 9.4 g fat
  8. 8 Toaster strudel pastries

    Toaster strudel pastries

    Pillsbury
    d NOVA 4 309 kcal 18.2 g sugar 3.6 g protein 10.9 g fat
  9. 9 Sticky Cinnamon Toaster Pastries

    Sticky Cinnamon Toaster Pastries

    Flings
    d NOVA 4 364 kcal 15.9 g sugar 31.8 g protein 13.6 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free

  10. 10 Toaster pastries, frosted strawberry

    Toaster pastries, frosted strawberry

    pop tarts · 624 g
    d NOVA 4 385 kcal 30.8 g sugar 3.9 g protein 9.6 g fat

How we built this list

We ranked all published toaster pastries on Foodmetria that have a photo and the required nutrition data, using values per 100 g from the product label. Ties are broken by Nutri-Score and by how often shoppers scan the product. Rankings update automatically as label data changes. Read our methodology.

More toaster pastries rankings