Top 10 · Updated October 2026

Highest-Protein Pumpkin Pies

Pumpkin pies: typically 4 g of protein per 100 g (median of 64 products). The pumpkin pies with the most protein per 100 g. Useful if you are trying to increase your protein intake. We checked 39 pumpkin pies with complete data.

1

Pumpkin Pie

Nature's promise

d 256 kcal 29.6 g sugar 5.6 g protein 8 g fat
2

Pumpkin pie

· 37 oz

d NOVA 4 282 kcal 25.2 g sugar 5.3 g protein 11.5 g fat
3

Pumpkin Pie, Pumpkin

Jessie Lord · 22 oz/624 g

d NOVA 4 250 kcal 18.3 g sugar 4.8 g protein 11.5 g fat
4

Pumpkin Pie

Walmart · 22 oz

d NOVA 4 296 kcal 23.2 g sugar 4.8 g protein 13.6 g fat
5

Pumpkin Pie

Rocky Mountain Pies · 22 oz

d NOVA 4 264 kcal 19.2 g sugar 4.8 g protein 11.2 g fat
6

Pumpkin pie

Marie Callender's

d 281 kcal 28.9 g sugar 4.7 g protein 10.9 g fat
7

Pumpkin pie

Trader Joe's · 27 oz

e 328 kcal 25.8 g sugar 4.7 g protein 12.5 g fat
8

Pumpkin Pie

HEB

d 287 kcal 21.3 g sugar 4.1 g protein 13.1 g fat
9

Pumpkin Pie

Great Value

d NOVA 4 280 kcal 20 g sugar 4 g protein 12.8 g fat

Also: Palm oil free · No additives
10

Pumpkin Pie

The Kroger Co.

d NOVA 4 284 kcal 17.6 g sugar 3.9 g protein 13.7 g fat

Also: Palm oil free

How we built this list

We ranked all published pumpkin pies on Foodmetria that have a photo and the required nutrition data, using values per 100 g from the product label. Ties are broken by Nutri-Score and by how often shoppers scan the product. Rankings update automatically as label data changes. Read our methodology.

More pumpkin pies rankings

Healthiest Pumpkin Pies by Nutri-Score Least Processed Pumpkin Pies Lowest-Calorie Pumpkin Pies Best Low-Sugar Pumpkin Pies All pumpkin pies