Comparison

Shepherd’s pie vs Hachis parmentier

Overall, Shepherd’s pie has the better nutritional profile on the measures we compare. It wins on 6 of our comparison points versus 1.

Nutrition per 100 g

NutrientShepherd’s pieHachis parmentier
Nutri-Score c c
NOVA group 4 4
Calories 100 kcal 186 kcal
Fat 3.7 g 13 g
Saturated fat 2.1 g 4.5 g
Sugars 1.1 g 1.8 g
Salt 0.5 g 1 g
Fiber 1.4 g 0.9 g
Protein 5.4 g 8 g
Additives12
AllergensGluten, MilkGluten, Milk

Green = better value for that nutrient (less sugar, fat, salt and calories; more fiber and protein).

Key differences

  • Shepherd’s pie has 46% fewer calories (100 kcal vs 186 kcal).
  • Shepherd’s pie has 72% less fat (3.7 g vs 13 g).
  • Shepherd’s pie has 53% less saturated fat (2.1 g vs 4.5 g).
  • Shepherd’s pie has 39% less sugar (1.1 g vs 1.8 g).
  • Shepherd’s pie has 45% less salt (0.5 g vs 1 g).
  • Shepherd’s pie has 36% more fiber (1.4 g vs 0.9 g).
  • Hachis parmentier has 32% more protein (8 g vs 5.4 g).

Ingredients

Shepherd’s pie

Potato (46%), Lamb (21%), Vegetables (14%) (onion, carrot, swede), Water, Butter (milk), Milk, Cornflour, Salt, Tomato purée, Wheat flour (wheat flour, iron, thiamin, nicotinic acid, calcium carbonate), Colour (plain caramel), Pepper, Brown sugar, rosemary, garlic.

Hachis parmentier

64,5 % purée de pomme de terre [eau, pomme de terre déshydratée, crème (LAIT), huile decolza, LAIT entier en poudre, beurre (LAIT), sel, épices], 29 % viande de porc, 3,3 % fromage(LAIT), 2,7 % oignon, 1,2 % concentré de tomate, farine de BLÉ (gluten), amidon modifié, sel,amidon, épices et plantes aromatiques, stabilisant (E461), sucre, ail, lactose (LAIT), dextrose.

FAQ

Which is healthier: Shepherd’s pie or Hachis parmentier?

Overall, Shepherd’s pie has the better nutritional profile on the measures we compare. We compare Nutri-Score, processing level and seven nutrients per 100 g. Your own needs (for example low sugar or high protein) may make a different choice better for you.

Which has fewer calories?

Shepherd’s pie has fewer calories: 100 kcal versus 186 kcal per 100 g.

Which has less sugar?

Shepherd’s pie has less sugar: 1.1 g versus 1.8 g per 100 g.

More comparisons