Top 10 · Updated November 2026

Healthiest Creamy Peanut Butters by Nutri-Score

10 of the top 10 creamy peanut butters products carry Nutri-Score A; the rest score A or better. The creamy peanut butters with the best Nutri-Score grades. Among products with the same grade, the one with the better nutrition score ranks higher. We checked 72 creamy peanut butters with complete data.

  1. 1 Smooth Peanut Butter

    Smooth Peanut Butter

    Meridian · 280 g
    a NOVA 1 607 kcal 5.3 g sugar 26 g protein 47 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free · Vegan · Vegetarian

  2. 2 Peanut Butter

    Peanut Butter

    Meridian · 470g
    a NOVA 1 607 kcal 5.3 g sugar 26 g protein 47.3 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free · Vegan · Vegetarian

  3. 3 Smooth Peanut Butter (made with 100% nuts)

    Smooth Peanut Butter (made with 100% nuts)

    Tesco · 340 g
    a NOVA 1 622 kcal 6.5 g sugar 28.4 g protein 49.4 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free · Vegan · Vegetarian

  4. 4 Peanut butter

    Peanut butter

    Smucker's · 16 oz (1 lb) (454 g)
    a NOVA 1 563 kcal 3.1 g sugar 25 g protein 50 g fat

    Also: No additives

  5. 5 Peanut butter smooth

    Peanut butter smooth

    Cherokee River · 350 g
    a 608 kcal 5.4 g sugar 30 g protein 47 g fat
  6. 6 Beurre de Cacahuète

    Beurre de Cacahuète

    · 340 g
    a NOVA 4 617 kcal 8.5 g sugar 25 g protein 49 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free · No additives

  7. 7 Creamy Peanut Butter

    Creamy Peanut Butter

    Simply Nature
    a NOVA 2 594 kcal 6.3 g sugar 25 g protein 50 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free · Vegan · Vegetarian

  8. 8 Crema de cacahuete

    Crema de cacahuete

    KOMERFISH S.A.
    a NOVA 1 610 kcal 5.9 g sugar 22.8 g protein 49.1 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free · Vegan · Vegetarian

  9. 9 Peanut Butter

    Peanut Butter

    Once Again · 16 oz
    a NOVA 2 594 kcal 6.7 g sugar 26.7 g protein 46.7 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free · Vegan · Vegetarian

  10. 10 Smooth Peanut Butter

    Smooth Peanut Butter

    pip & nut · 300 g
    a NOVA 3 593 kcal 6.6 g sugar 27 g protein 49 g fat

    Also: Palm oil free · Vegan · Vegetarian

How we built this list

We ranked all published creamy peanut butters on Foodmetria that have a photo and the required nutrition data, using values per 100 g from the product label. Ties are broken by Nutri-Score and by how often shoppers scan the product. Rankings update automatically as label data changes. Read our methodology.

More creamy peanut butters rankings