Top 10 · Updated October 2026

Healthiest Peanut Butter Cups by Nutri-Score

1 of the top 10 peanut butter cups products carry Nutri-Score B; the rest score D or better. The peanut butter cups with the best Nutri-Score grades. Among products with the same grade, the one with the better nutrition score ranks higher. We checked 89 peanut butter cups with complete data.

1

Mixed Nut Butter with Seeds

Kirkland Signature · 1.68 lb

b NOVA 3 209 kcal 1 g sugar 8 g protein 17 g fat

Also: Palm oil free · Vegan · Vegetarian
2

Peanut butter buttons

c NOVA 3 309 kcal 3 g sugar 4 g protein 25 g fat

Also: Palm oil free · Vegetarian · No additives
3

Chocolate Peantu Butter Keto Fat Cups

Keto Science · 8.4 oz

c 90 kcal 1 g sugar 1 g protein 8 g fat
4

Chocolate Peanut Butter

c 294 kcal 11.8 g sugar 58.8 g protein 0 g fat
5

Twin Pack Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

LILY'S · 1.25 oz

c NOVA 4 180 kcal 1 g sugar 4 g protein 15 g fat
6

Peanut Butter Cup

c NOVA 4 395 kcal 10.5 g sugar 26.3 g protein 13.2 g fat
7

Peanut butter have

Jonesbar · 12 servings per container and 180 calories

c 383 kcal 29.8 g sugar 10.6 g protein 17 g fat

Also: Vegan · Vegetarian · No additives
8

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Trader Joe's · 454 g

d NOVA 4 187 kcal 18 g sugar 2 g protein 11 g fat
9

Peanut Butter Cups - Dark Chocolate

Choc Zero · 3 oz

d NOVA 4 494 kcal 0 g sugar 14.1 g protein 35.3 g fat

Also: Palm oil free
10

Peanut Butter Cups

QUESt

d 476 kcal 2.4 g sugar 26.2 g protein 35.7 g fat

How we built this list

We ranked all published peanut butter cups on Foodmetria that have a photo and the required nutrition data, using values per 100 g from the product label. Ties are broken by Nutri-Score and by how often shoppers scan the product. Rankings update automatically as label data changes. Read our methodology.

More peanut butter cups rankings

Highest-Protein Peanut Butter Cups Least Processed Peanut Butter Cups Lowest-Calorie Peanut Butter Cups Best Low-Sugar Peanut Butter Cups All peanut butter cups