Top 10 · Updated October 2026
Healthiest Extra-Mature Cheddar by Nutri-Score
10 of the top 10 extra-mature cheddar products carry Nutri-Score D; the rest score D or better. The extra-mature cheddar with the best Nutri-Score grades. Among products with the same grade, the one with the better nutrition score ranks higher. We checked 49 extra-mature cheddar with complete data.
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
Premium Cheddar Extra Mature
British heritage · 125 gAlso: Palm oil free · Vegetarian · No additives
-
6
-
7
-
8
-
9
Extra Mature Cheddar
Pilgrims Choice -
10
Extra mature cheddar
Coop · 400 g
How we built this list
We ranked all published extra-mature cheddar on Foodmetria that have a photo and the required nutrition data, using values per 100 g from the product label. Ties are broken by Nutri-Score and by how often shoppers scan the product. Rankings update automatically as label data changes. Read our methodology.